The title ‘The Butterfly Effect’ refers to an example of chaos theory, and the idea that every single little thing we do can shape our future drastically – for example, does the small flap of a butterfly’s wings create a tidal wave somewhere in the world, eventually? What would happen if we could go back and do things differently? How different would the outcome be? Personally, I love the idea that every tiny decision that we make, without even thinking, can have such an impact on us; I often pass a lot of time thinking ‘what if?’, and for this reason, the film had a big effect on me, leaving me unable to sleep because I was so wrapped up in these hypothetical situations!
The film follows Evan (played predominantly by Ashton Kutcher, but also played by Logan Lerman and John Amedori as his younger self). As a child, he has black outs whenever he’s put in a stressful or uncomfortable situation, which include being forced to take part in child pornography by the abusive father (Eric Stolz) of his childhood sweetheart, Kayleigh (Amy Smart); being strangled by his institutionalised father who is then killed in front him; seeing his dog burned alive by Tommy (Kayleigh’s brother); and killing a woman and her baby while playing with dynamite with his friends. He is advised by his psychologist to keep journals, and when he rediscovers these, years later, he also uncovers the ability to travel back in time and is able to relive these traumatic parts of his past.
However, every time he goes back in time to change something (always with good intentions), he comes back to the present day a changed man – at one point, he finds himself crying over Kayleigh’s grave, after she kills herself; one time, he is an amputee; another, he’s an inmate, imprisoned for murdering Tommy. The people around him are also affected; Kayleigh ranges from being the most popular girl in a sorority to being a prostitute. All he really wants is for him and Kayleigh to be happy and together, but something always seems to go wrong. On top of this, years’ worth of new memories causes him severe brain damage, and eventually he realises that everyone’s suffering, in every scenario, is ultimately caused by him in some way.
There are four potential endings to this film; one is a rather cliched ending where he walks past Kayleigh on the street, she stops and looks at him for a while as though she knows him, then shrugs it off and walks on.
The generic ‘happy’ ending is where they cross paths on the street, and Evan introduces himself to Kayleigh, asking her out for coffee.
A more open-ended alternative is similar to the one where Evan and Kayleigh pass each other on the sidewalk and keep walking, except this time Evan, after hesitating, turns and follows Kayleigh, leaving it ambiguous.
The last possible ending is where he travels back to his own birth and strangles himself with his own umbilical cord so he was never born. Considering how wonderfully complicated the film is, I prefer this ending, as the others seem a bit of a let down.
The acting in this film is incredible; Ashton Kutcher portrays pretty much every ‘side’ to a personality possible; and I love the way the film is shot, because each new scenario seems to represent a different genre, showing how versatile the actors are. The different genres means there’s definitely something for everyone in this film, yet it’s still quite easy to follow despite how complicated it is; I would quite happily recommend it to everyone, with hesitation.
This is a song by one of my favourite bands, set to clips from The Butterfly Effect; this is actually one of the reasons I watched it in the first place.